Pakistani farmers seek flood damages from two German companies

Pakistani farmers want German companies to pay for flood losses, but can emissions establish responsibility across borders?

Abdul Hafeez Khoso and 38 other farmers from Pakistan’s Sindh province are suing German energy company RWE and cement maker Heidelberg Materials for damage from the 2022 floods. [5] Their case argues that the companies’ greenhouse-gas emissions contributed to climate change and intensified rainfall…

Published

Open original · [5] Pakistan farmers in long fight to make German firms pay for flood damage | AFP.com — afp.com

Visual Cheatsheet Version A for Pakistani farmers seek flood damages from two German companies. Full text follows for assistive technology.
Abdul Hafeez Khoso and 38 other farmers from Pakistan’s Sindh province are suing German energy company RWE and cement maker Heidelberg Materials for damage from the 2022 floods. [5] Their case argues that the companies’ greenhouse-gas emissions contributed to climate change and intensified rainfall that destroyed crops, livestock and homes; both companies deny wrongdoing. [5] Why it matters: The farmers are seeking to make companies pay for climate damage far from their headquarters, rather than for specific operations in Pakistan. Their claim tests a route through which people losing homes and livelihoods to extreme weather could pursue compensation from industrial emitters abroad. [5] Key insights: The claim targets global emissions rather than pollution from either company’s operations in Pakistan. [5] | The plaintiffs estimate RWE’s contribution to global industrial emissions at 0.68 percent and Heidelberg Materials’ at 0.12 percent; these are the farmers’ estimates, not findings established in this case. [5] | A recent German legal case opened the door to such lawsuits, providing the legal context for the farmers’ action. [5] Cheatsheet facts: What happened: Thirty-nine Sindh farmers are pursuing RWE and Heidelberg Materials for losses from Pakistan’s 2022 floods. [5] | Why: They argue that the firms’ emissions contributed to warming and intensified the rain that destroyed their crops, livestock and homes. [5] | Who pays: The farmers want the German energy and cement companies to pay damages, citing estimated industrial-emissions shares of 0.68 percent and 0.12 percent respectively. [5] | The catch: Both companies deny wrongdoing; the claim rests on responsibility for global emissions, not specific operations in Pakistan. [5]
X copy pack
Download cheatsheet PNG

Edition complete

You've reached the end of this edition.

Free to start. You'll create an account, then confirm the link before anything runs.

Create your own briefings — freeRead the full editionBrowse every cheatsheetRead in Briefings